Skip to main content

Book Review Intuitive Eating

Image of the Intuitive Eating book 4th edition
Buy On Amazon
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

I finally finished reading through all of my notes that I was making as I read through the 4th edition of the Intuitive Eating: A Revolutionary Anti-Diet Approach book by Evelyn Tribole and Elyse Resch and decided to compare it to PN as part of my review).

I would say that this is definitely a comprehensive guide that promotes a harmonious relationship with food, body, and mind. The book challenges traditional diet culture and encourages readers to listen to their body's natural hunger and satiety cues. This edition includes updated research, new insights, and practical tools to help readers reconnect with their internal signals which I appreciate that they are keeping the book current so that the latest information is in there.

I think that it is important to understand the history of the book and was thrilled to see that they included not only personal stories but studies as well to help understand why they were making different recommendations.

This book is not the easiest to read because there is a lot of information packed in, quizzes and questions to ask yourself along the way as you read through and I took a lot of notes. It looks like there is also a companion workbook as well but I haven't ordered it.

Key Concepts

1. Reject the Diet Mentality The book starts by encouraging readers to discard diet culture and its restrictive rules, which often lead to a cycle of guilt and deprivation.

2. Honor Your Hunger Understanding and responding to natural hunger signals is emphasized as a way to maintain energy and avoid overeating.

3. Make Peace with Food Readers are guided to stop categorizing foods as "good" or "bad" and to allow themselves to eat without guilt.

4. Challenge the Food Police The book tackles internal and external voices that promote diet culture and body shaming.

5. Respect Your Fullness It’s important to recognize when you’re comfortably full and to stop eating at that point.

6. Discover the Satisfaction Factor Finding joy and satisfaction in eating helps enhance the overall experience and prevents overeating.

7. Honor Your Feelings Without Using Food The authors provide strategies for coping with emotions without turning to food for comfort.

8. Respect Your Body Accepting your genetic blueprint and treating your body with respect is a key message.

9. Exercise—Feel the Difference The focus is on finding enjoyable movement rather than exercising for the sole purpose of weight loss.

10. Honor Your Health—Gentle Nutrition Making food choices that honor your health and taste buds while making you feel well.

Baby-Led Weaning 

I was thrilled to see that Intuitive Eating (4th Edition) discusses baby-led weaning. As an IBCLC, this is very important to me. Just like breastfeeding and paced bottle feeding, baby-led weaning allows babies to set the pace and respect their hunger and satiety cues. This approach not only supports healthy development but also fosters a positive relationship with food from the very beginning. Seeing this method highlighted in the book reinforces the importance of respecting our bodies' natural signals at every stage of life. 

Personal Connection

One of the coaches in a live session recommended "Intuitive Eating," and it turned out to be a valuable addition to my journey. As I am currently enrolled in the Precision Nutrition for Women program, I found that the themes in "Intuitive Eating" complemented the program beautifully. Both approaches emphasize listening to your body and making mindful choices that support overall well-being.

PN Program vs the Intuitive Eating Book

I wanted to include in the review the differences and seminaries that I have founds between the PN Coaching program and the book.

Philosophy and Approach

Intuitive Eating

Emphasizes a non-diet, self-compassionate approach that prioritizes mental and emotional well-being alongside physical health. It encourages individuals to trust their body's innate wisdom and promotes a guilt-free relationship with food.

Precision Nutrition

While it also promotes a balanced, individualized approach to nutrition, it tends to focus more on structured guidance and measurable progress. PN provides specific strategies, habit-based coaching, and educational resources to help individuals achieve their health and fitness goals.

Structure and Guidance

Intuitive Eating

Less structured, more flexible. It provides principles rather than rules, allowing for personal interpretation and adaptation. The approach is highly individualized and emphasizes internal cues over external guidelines.

Precision Nutrition

More structured with clear, actionable steps. It uses a habit-based coaching model that provides regular check-ins, feedback, and adjustments based on individual progress. There’s a strong emphasis on goal-setting and accountability - goal setting isn't about weight or size which was surprising as it can be, but the goals we use are very personal.

Target Audience

Intuitive Eating

Ideal for those who have struggled with chronic dieting, eating disorders, or a negative relationship with food and body image. It’s particularly beneficial for individuals looking to break free from diet culture and embrace a more intuitive approach to eating.

Precision Nutrition

Suited for those seeking a more structured approach to improving their nutrition and fitness. It’s beneficial for individuals with specific health or performance goals, people who have struggle with calorie counting, including athletes, fitness enthusiasts, and those looking to make significant lifestyle changes and looking to have a healthy relationship with nutrition and exercise.

Psychological and Emotional Focus

Intuitive Eating

Deeply rooted in psychology and emotional well-being. It addresses the mental and emotional aspects of eating, including body image and self-esteem.

Precision Nutrition

While it acknowledges the importance of psychology in behavior change, the focus is more on practical strategies and measurable outcomes. Emotional and psychological aspects are considered, but not as deeply as in "Intuitive Eating" unless you want that to be the focus, which for me I am including in my journey with PN and why the coach recommend the book.

Scientific Support

Intuitive Eating

Backed by research on the negative impacts of dieting and the benefits of intuitive eating on mental and physical health. The book includes references to studies supporting its principles.

Precision Nutrition

Strongly evidence-based with a focus on scientific research to support its recommendations. PN provides detailed explanations of the science behind its methods and frequently updates its content based on the latest research.

Final Thoughts

"Intuitive Eating" (4th Edition) offers a refreshing, compassionate approach to eating that encourages self-trust and body positivity. It contrasts with the Precision Nutrition program, which provides a more structured, goal-oriented framework. Both approaches have their merits, and the choice between them depends on individual needs and preferences. For those looking to break free from diet culture and embrace a more intuitive, flexible approach, "Intuitive Eating" is an excellent resource. For those seeking structured guidance and measurable progress plus getting to trust yourself and feeling good about your body, the Precision Nutrition program offers a comprehensive and scientifically supported path to achieving health and fitness goals.

Labels:
Location: Canada

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Day 22: Unplanned Wins and Deepening Insights

Thanks for coming by to share in my quest for health! A Shift in Plans Leads to an Unexpected Victory Today's workout, intertwined with guided meditation and a brisk walk, took an unexpected turn. My initial plan to meditate by the lake was thwarted by my eager dog who for once didn't stop and sniff every few feet as we went along, leading to an impromptu 29-minute cardio session during our 40-minute walk—a serendipitous outcome that surpassed my expectations.  The meditation, which I later conducted at home, revealed a surprise requirement to remove my shoes, an aspect that wouldn't have aligned with my original lakeside setting. This twist of fate underscored the notion that sometimes, things unfold exactly as they should. Unlock a Healthier You: The Holistic Benefits of Meditation! Reflecting on Objectives and Behaviors The day's lesson delved into the distinction between objectives and behaviors, emphasizing the power we hold over our actions rather than the outcome
Post a Comment
Read more

The First Step with Precision Nutrition: A Deep Dive into Personalization

Embarking on a new health and wellness journey can be both exhilarating and daunting. But my first step with Precision Nutrition's women's program – filling out their detailed questionnaire – turned out to be an unexpectedly enlightening experience. It was more than just a formality; it was a deep dive into my health, lifestyle, and expectations. The Thorough Questionnaire After registering for the program, I received an email with a comprehensive questionnaire. I was surprised to see that I had dedicated a good half hour to complete it, and every minute was worth it. The questions covered a wide range of topics: from injuries and restrictions to allergies, health issues, exercise levels, available equipment, medications, sleep patterns, and any supplements I was taking.  Personalization at Its Core What impressed me the most was the level of detail in the questions. They inquired about my specific health conditions, including PCOS and IBS, which have been significant factors i
Post a Comment
Read more

Day 24: Valentine's Reflections and Embracing Every Moment

Welcome back, followers of well-being! A Surprising Lesson on Binge Eating Valentine's Day brought with it an unexpected lesson from the program, focusing on the concept of binge eating. The lesson didn't delve into definitions but rather suggested an intriguing approach: if binge eating occurs, do it slowly and without any guilt. For those who don't experience binge eating, the guidance was to maintain the practice of eating slowly throughout the day. This perspective offers a unique lens on mindfulness and self-compassion, encouraging us to be present and intentional with our eating habits, regardless of the situation. The Continual Growth Through Meditation Today's workout seamlessly blended meditation with walking, a combination that has become a cherished part of my routine. The guided meditations, each building upon the last one, have become a source of solace and anticipation. Their evolving nature keeps me engaged and hopeful that they'll remain a cornerston
Post a Comment
Read more